Features of critical thinking 

Critical thinking is a complex process of deliberation, which features the skills listed in below.  You can use these headings as a structured set of steps, perhaps as a form you fill in, to help you break down the stages of developing your argument.  
Identify
Identify a range of positions on a particular issue. Compare and contrast opposing views.
Judge
Judge the credibility of the sources. Is there any bias, prejudice or self-interest?
Evaluate
Evaluate the opposing arguments, based on the evidence presented.
Synthesise
Bring together a range of evidence to make your point.
Draw conclusions 
Come to your own conclusions based on your own line of argument.
Present
Present your argument clearly, in a manner to persuade others.
End.
www.ed.ac.uk/iad